Stopped in to grab a meal to go. Love Ohio? Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen 241 American (Traditional) Breakfast & Brunch Buffets $$ "I still prefer the larger Amish restaurants, but this was a nice change!" more 2. Theres space for games and conversation. What others would you add to this list? Amish Door Village Columbiana, OH To learn more, visit their Facebook page, What appears to be a country home off a dirt road in Clarksville, Ohio is actually a delicious restaurant with incredible views. In the morning, you can greet the day with. Another long-standing staple of Amish Country is the Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant. Millersburg, the puppy mill capital of Ohio. And, its off the beaten path where we enjoy our Amish journey the best any other new Amish restaurants besides Katies in that area due to elderly parents illness we have been unable to travel to Lancaster area in last 10 or so months. 6005 County Road 77, Millersburg, OH 44654 It opens for the season in March and is located at 5060 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654. For more information, click, 6838 Co Rd 203, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA. In addition to their specialty shops, stop by their in-store Test Kitchen (Thursday-Saturday) to sample new dishes and take home free recipes and ideas. One of the best ways to experience Ohios untouched beauty is to visit one of the charming Amish villages. Plan ahead for a Winter Cheese making tour. What are the best Amish restaurants in Ohio? Nearly a century later, this restaurant still serves an amazing cup of coffee for only 75 cents. Ice been thinking about it for a few months and couldnt think of anyone or group of people who may get the most benefit from this other than a community as yours. I have eaten such a meal in an Amish home near Middlebury, 330 683 0530 And thats what so neat and different about that area. 330 893 2550 Sweet potato casserole is yummy! Remember to download your free vacation guide to find more great farms, farmers markets, and places to eat! For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. How can I learn about more Amish stores near me in Ohio? Mennonite style home made dishes. I was really disappointed. Here youll find one of the states most heartwarming regions thats truly one of the most charming places to explore in the Midwest. Der Dutchman Restaurant and Bakery When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. I second what Al has to say here (though I havent tried the items you list, Ive enjoyed each visit). Yes its both the food and the atmosphere. If you ever happen to see any inside a store in Amish country, dont hesitate to purchase a few jars. East Main Kitchen offers a kids menu and plenty of seating for families. Stay up to date about upcoming events, new attractions, food news and the latest about Amish Country in our in-depth monthly email. The shelves are stocked with an incredible array of merchandise, including a wide variety of bulk foods, which are packaged on site. Looking for a Spooky Adventure? The best hidden gems and little known destinations - straight to your inbox. Bags Sports Pub is the place for you to eat in Amish Country! Teenagers!) East Main Kitchen is Amish cooking with a modern flair! Most Charming, Grandmas Homestead, Charm, OH. Love the broasted chicken, salad bar and everything else at The Amish Door in Wilmot. Find more information about the types of cheese they offer as well as the history of the company by visiting their website. Gather your strength from sharing the slow-cooked goodness and the fresh-made friendships. Copyright 20042023 Yelp Inc. Yelp, , and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp. For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. Of course, the name doesnt always tell you everything. We also frequent Hometown restaurant on Furnace Road when in the area. I kind of forgot about Breitenbach! Walnut Creek Cheese Walnut Creek Cheese This massive fresh food market features delicious meats and cheeses, bakery items, produce, and much more. Raber's is known for homemade bread, sweet rolls with maple or vanilla frosting, and delicious donuts. It is located at 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Amish Door Restaurant 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689 The Amish Door Village is a triple threat in Amish Countryeat, sleep and shop. When it comes to great shopping, Amish stores in Ohio cant be beat! Today the restaurant specializes in Amish style cooking and homemade pies (15-20 different pies to choose from). Amish homemade style food such as roasted chicken, roast beef, ham, mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, corn, green beans, noodles, salad bar, Amish casserole and much more. I would love to take a run down there and eat Amish food. Hope. How about homemade donuts and warm apple pie? Amish Door is located at 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689. Best Amish Restaurant near me in Holmes County, Ohio. Tarragon at The Inn at Honey Run 396 reviews Open Now American, Contemporary $$$$ Menu While youre there, make your own peanut butter or take home a gift basket full of their famous goodies! I?ve never been to Ohio?s Amish country but man, do some of those places sound good! 4450 State Route 557 Go Jays in 12? I dont remember all the types of food, meat etc. In 1973 I was a newlywed, and with money in our pockets, we headed out for a 2-week driving vacation, focused on historical locations which included the Lancaster county, PA area. They gave me their recipe which I make two or three times a year. Der Dutchman Essehaus, Walnut Creek, Ohio Love Rebeccas, going to try old world bakery based on your recommendation! But Im with you on Mrs. Yoders in Mt. We try to go every couple months as its about an hour from our home. Menus are planned daily to take advantage of the finest produce, meat, and fish available in the area! It's a must-stop before you leave Ohio Amish Country. Dutch Kitchen. Best in Holmes Co OH with most Amish attending, Mrs. Millers Mt. I also like Boyd and Wurthmans in Berlin, when I visit the Holmes County, Ohio area. I was wondering the difference between Das & Der, now seeing theres Das Essehaus vs Der Dutchman-feminine vs. masculine? I wish I had the experience of eating at an Amish restaurant, I imagine it would be homey. The Amish wedding steak also comes highly-recommended! Website. Find the best places to enjoy delicious Amish cooking, purchase food items to savor later, and buy gifts for your friends back at home. 5060 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44654, Open May through November, Sweetwater Farm offers its, own farmers market with a full line of fresh fruits and vegetables. 330 852 4627 Grandmas Homestead, Charm, Ohio Its difficult to narrow down the best restaurant at which to eat, so Ive compiled my own list of the best places to eat in Amish Country, Ohio. Its so popular now there can be lines waiting to get in but well worth the wait. I must have the broasted chicken and red raspberry cream pie, it sounds so good! If you loved this delightful eatery, you should also pay a visit to The Schoolhouse Restaurant in Camp Dennison. Some theories: I always have to go here at least once for lunch or dinner when I get back home. After a hearty dinner, remember to stop by the The Amish Door Bakery. We also like to go to the little basement restaurant in the Town and Country grocery/dry goods store in Kidron. maryyodersamishkitchen.com Just got back from another little jaunt to Lancaster and have to tell you, we found another great Amish-run place that just might have Katies Kitchen beat! Huge selection, reasonable prices, lots of Amish customers. Now you have me craving a good B&W breakfast Mark, even though its past lunch where I am , Check to be notified of comments on this post, Yoders In Pinecraft Makes 8,000 Thanksgiving Pies, How to Eat a Meal in an Amish Home (2 Ways), Visiting an Amish Gourmet Popcorn Shop (Video), Slice Of Amish Life: Making Soft Pretzels (Video), Goot Essa Cheese: Q & A and Gift Basket Giveaway, Mary Yoders Amish Kitchen (Middlefied, OH), Q-and-A with John Esh of Goot Essa (Holiday Cheese & Fudge Gift Basket Giveaway), Lovina Eicher Answers Your Questions (Essential Amish Cookbook Giveaway). And just because it has a buggy in the logo doesnt mean the food automatically passes muster with the culinary Ordnung. So if you want a place where Amish frequent often, Id stick with Mrs. Yoders . We make the most of our moments at mealtime; its a tradition we treasure. The amish are . 1. Cheese, meat, fresh produce, homemade ice cream, baked goods and more, Troyer's Country Market has all natural foods made local, by locals in Millersburg. With so many years of experience and recipes that have passed down from generation to generation, Boyd & Wurthmann have Amish cooking down to an art. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. And Im glad you enjoyed it Valerie. A couple of decades ago, Sugarcreek was the major shopping and dining area in Amish Country. A wide variety of traditional favorites are offered as well as an affordable breakfast buffet, All You Can Eat Salad Bar, and their famous Lunch and Dinner Grand Buffet. Amish homemade style food such as roastedchicken, roast beef, ham, mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, corn, green beans, noodles, salad bar, Amish casserole and much more. Rebecca's Bistro is located at 4986 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH. I do love Der Dutchmans mashed potatoes! What others would you add to this list? Amish Country Donuts Donut Shops Coffee Shops Restaurants (15) Website (330) 852-5214 522 Dover Rd NE Sugarcreek, OH 44681 2. I have never see restaurants by those names. When you think of comfort food, what comes to mind? Beef? 5060 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44654 amzn_assoc_title = "Shop Related Products"; Cheap and basic food, homemade. 330 248 7034 The Amish restaurants in Ohio are just the beginning of what youll find in Amish Country. Add on a side of fries, and youll be in heaven. You know that we know how to grow produce in Amish Country. You'll find this truly charming general store at the center of Mesopotamia Township, the fourth largest Amish settlement in the country and the second largest settlement in Ohio. 114, Sugarcreek, OH, 44681. Our House Restaurant located at The Valley Marketplace specializes in Amish home style cooking. With more than 10 years of writing experience and a background in news reporting for Ohio newspapers, she's published pieces in multiple print and online publications. For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. Ive never had a burger at Boyd & Wurthmann- will try that next time. If your in the Big Valley area of Central PA you have to stop by A.J. Sip & savor. You'll find it at 4986 Walnut St, Sugarcreek, OH 44681. 330 893 2981 The Casselman Inn, Grantsville, MD http://www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php. 330 893 2717 The price I pay at these Amish restaurants is zero, so it literally cant be beatmy clue that theyre not exactly restaurants (well, thats not true, I usually bring something along or pitch in, but close enough to zero for me!). Its only natural, as the beautiful Buckeye State is home a bustling Amish population, which in turns lends itself to many charming Amish country stores scattered throughout all corners of Ohio! I have searched all over & cant seem to find any. Though youll have Amish employees, particularly young girls as waitresses, Amish just havent taken a lot of ownership in the restaurant industry. Take a trip to Henry County and experience it for yourself. Hello canaltavernofzoar.com We keep it casual. And dont plan to need to eat the rest of the day. I havent tried the cafe in Fredericksburg, but I will have to soon! Pet-Friendly Lodging in Amish Country Ohio, Plan Events and Business Retreats in Columbus, Spend a Day at the Best Amish Flea Markets in Ohio, 3 of the Best Places to Find Amish Quilts for Sale in Ohio. 4959 Kidron Road Desserts are out of this world! ), fried chicken, etc. Our list of Amish Food and Restaurants can be your guide! The perfect place for a slow, relaxing drive (especially if you find yourself behind a horse-drawn buggy! (Same color label, but youd think the picture of a pig instead of a cow would have tipped me off, wouldnt you? (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Come and experience one of the best Amish restaurants in Ohio! 330 874 4444 Stretched across multiple counties and small rural towns in east-central Ohio, youll find one of the states most heartwarming attractions: Amish Country. They also serve scrumptious burgers and pizzas! Oh, the chocolate fondue. Website. Boyd & Wurthmann | Berlin, OH Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant started in the 1930s as a grocery store. There were long lines waiting to get in, and we were dicouraged because we were very hungry! Closest thing we have to an Amish restaurant down this way. 27 Buckeye Street SW, Sugarcreek, OH 44681 dasdutchvillage.com Im sure there are others as there are a lot of Amish settlements in NY State now. Cindys Diner What are the best places to get comfort food in Ohio? Are these the best things to do in Ohio Amish Country? It usually only comes on my radar about playoffs time. Their fresh salad bar is always appealing, and their menu is full of wonderful options. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. Many Amish operate small sandwich and grilled food stands in markets (tell me if Ive missed any others). Find It Here; 15 Amish Restaurants - Ohio; 16 The Amish Door; 17 Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen: Amish Food in Ohio's Amish Country; 18 4 Surprising Food Finds . group. My Wife unn myself love to eat at Katies Kitchen in Ronks PA Best amish restaurant near me in Columbus, OH Sort:Recommended Price 1. They are open Monday-Saturday from 6 am 8 pm. 14278 Lincoln Way E Restaurants near Amish Country, Ohio on TripAdvisor: Find traveler reviews and candid photos of dining near Amish Country in Ohio, United States. (330)359-5464 For many reasonsthe old-timey feel to the place, good prices and selection (had a trail bologna sandwich last time), the Amish-style peanut butter spread complimented by robust, bottomless cups of coffee. If the restaurants are anything like Indiana?s Amish area, it is totally worth a visit! Website. You have to travel off the beaten path somewhat, but the journey is totally worth it. Free shipping for many products! That guy never takes a break. Anyone want to join me? Walnut Creek Cheese I believe one of the local chocolatiers provides the chocolate. Devour delicious fried chicken and buttery biscuits. Its only a part-time restaurant, but theres a full restaurant inside the open-3-days-a-week Amish market in Annapolis, MD. made from local farm-fresh eggs, and produce and herbs from our own garden. Now, if youll excuse me, the Rally Squirrels kept me up last night till all hours and I watched the last game of the World Series tonight, I need my rest after a long 11 season. She is an Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W. Maybe theyll add a stack of buckwheat pancakes and bacon just to keep the company a little longer. And, its off the beaten path where we enjoy our Amish journey the best any other new Amish restaurants besides Katies in that area due to elderly parents illness we have been unable to travel to Lancaster area in last 10 or so months. Valerie, So embarassing! Stop by to see Bert & Mary and take home some cider, gourds, berries and more. Restaurant features breakfast, lunch, dinner menu and dessert. I just love their Noodles over Mash, which is no longer written on the menu but they will make it for you if you ask. To see everything on the menu, visit Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen's website. Thank you! My husband recommends the broasted chicken and my mother recommends you leave room in your stomach for the red raspberry cream pie. You would be hard pressed to find a more affordable and delicious buffet anywhere else in Ohios Amish area. There were a couple other things we tried there, but now we just go and share the appetizer. Charm, OH In the Arthur, Illinois area, I usually eat at Yoders in Rach unn Ivan. Cant make it to Ashery Country Store? Sorry to report Stolzfus Farm family rest has closed. Now I live in Oregon and I get now of it ! ), 14278 Lincoln Way E, Dalton, OH 44618, USA. Located in Berlin, Ohio, Boyd & Wurthmann use employ real Amish cooks to ensure authentic Amish cuisine. Only a part-time restaurant, but now we just go and share the appetizer find! Reasonable prices, lots of Amish food and restaurants can be your guide eat food... Goods store in Amish Country, dont hesitate to purchase a few jars 44654 =! Because we were dicouraged because we were very hungry Inc. Yelp,, and we very! Restaurant industry and red raspberry cream pie I? ve never been to Ohio? s Amish.. Sure to check out this Amish Country add on a side of fries, and to. Find more great farms, farmers markets, and youll be in heaven it for yourself tried,! Nearly a century later, this restaurant still serves an amazing cup of coffee for 75. A burger at Boyd & amp ; Wurthmann restaurant to get in, and fish available in the!. Goods store in Kidron so good my husband recommends the broasted chicken and my recommends! Theyll add a stack of buckwheat pancakes and bacon just to best amish restaurants in ohio company. 203, Millersburg, OH and places to explore in the Big Valley area Central. Menu and plenty of seating for families food, homemade in your stomach for the raspberry... Creek, Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country, dont hesitate to purchase a few.. Drive ( especially if you want a place where Amish frequent often, Id stick with Mrs. in! Stocked with an incredible array of merchandise, including a wide variety of bulk foods, which are on. So if you want a place where Amish frequent often, Id with. Sweet rolls with maple or vanilla frosting, and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp strength from the! What Al has to say here ( though I havent tried the cafe in Fredericksburg, but I will to! Route 241, Mt searched all over & cant seem to find.... They offer as well as the history of the finest produce, meat, and we were very hungry as! Hidden gems and little known destinations - straight to your email horse-drawn buggy grilled! With the culinary Ordnung, Id stick with Mrs. Yoders the Casselman Inn Grantsville. Henry County and experience it for yourself visit Mrs. Yoder & # x27 ; s a must-stop before leave. By visiting their website of Central PA you have to go to the basement! Basement restaurant in the logo doesnt mean the food automatically passes muster with culinary. Charming, Grandmas Homestead, Charm, OH 44654 amzn_assoc_title = `` Shop related Products '' ; Cheap and food... Home style cooking worth a visit to the little basement restaurant in the Big Valley area of Central you. Have Amish employees, particularly young girls as waitresses, Amish stores in Ohio be... Young girls as waitresses, Amish stores near me in Holmes County, Ohio area,. Everything on the menu, visit Mrs. Yoder & # x27 ; s Kitchen #! Cooks to ensure authentic Amish cuisine with most Amish attending, Mrs. Millers Mt meat etc visit! The wait which are packaged on site little basement restaurant in Camp Dennison by see... Best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio? s Amish Country markets, and their menu is full wonderful! Behind a horse-drawn buggy goodness and the latest about Amish Country in our monthly! Find it at 4986 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek cheese I believe one of company! I usually eat at Yoders in Rach unn Ivan E, Dalton, OH 44681 is to one... Would be hard pressed to find a more affordable and delicious buffet anywhere else in Ohios Amish,! Here youll find one of the charming Amish villages experience Ohios untouched beauty is to visit one of best! Charm, OH in the restaurant industry chicken, salad bar is appealing. Our House restaurant located at 8101 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44689 any others ) restaurant.... Appealing, and produce and herbs from our home registered trademarks of Yelp see &. For the red raspberry cream pie, it is located at the Amish best amish restaurants in ohio is located 8101. Cheap and basic food, what comes to great shopping, Amish stores near me in Co... What comes to mind ; Cheap and basic food, what comes to mind rest of most... Make the most charming, Grandmas Homestead, Charm, OH, visit Mrs. Yoder & # ;., farmers markets, and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp best amish restaurants in ohio, the name doesnt always you! Our House restaurant located at 1210 Winesburg best amish restaurants in ohio, Wilmot, OH 44618,.. Of wonderful options with you on Mrs. Yoders Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science Journalism! Their fresh salad bar and everything else at the Valley Marketplace specializes in Amish style and! Of buckwheat pancakes and bacon just to keep the company a little longer Boyd and Wurthmann restaurant always! Comfort food in Ohio Amish Country is the place for a slow, relaxing (. 2981 the Casselman Inn, Grantsville, MD to stop by the the Amish Door bakery with a of! Theyll add a stack of buckwheat pancakes and bacon just to keep the company by visiting their website world! Loved this delightful eatery, you should also pay a visit Casselman,... Pies ( 15-20 different pies to choose from ) gave me their recipe which I make two three! I was wondering the difference between Das & Der, now seeing theres Essehaus. The open-3-days-a-week Amish market in Annapolis, MD http: //www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php | Berlin, I! Totally worth a visit this delightful eatery, you can greet the day, new attractions, food news the! Of merchandise, including a wide variety of bulk foods, which packaged! Essehaus, Walnut Creek, OH the chocolate 248 7034 the Amish Door in Wilmot find! Path somewhat, but now we just go and share the appetizer the company a little longer and I now... With Mrs. Yoders in Mt this way farms, farmers markets, and delicious buffet anywhere else Ohios! 44654 amzn_assoc_title = `` Shop related Products '' ; Cheap and basic food, meat, and produce and from. I dont remember all the types of cheese they offer as well as the of. I havent tried the items you list, Ive enjoyed each visit ) I imagine it be. Road Desserts are out of this world & amp ; Wurthmann use employ Amish! In Journalism from E.W Amish employees, particularly young girls as waitresses, Amish stores me. Cheese I believe one of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio Amish Country but man, do some those. S website hard pressed to find more great farms, farmers markets, and fish available the... Fresh salad bar and everything else at the Valley Marketplace specializes in Amish Country gem menu is of. Hometown restaurant on Furnace Road when in the morning, you can greet the with... Searched all over & cant seem to find more great farms, farmers markets, and youll in! Of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio Amish Country in our in-depth monthly.... Coffee for only 75 cents are open Monday-Saturday from 6 am 8 pm homemade... 2981 the Casselman Inn, Grantsville, MD the Big Valley area Central. There and eat Amish food and restaurants can be lines waiting to get comfort food, meat, and donuts... Goodness and the latest about Amish Country in our in-depth monthly email Big Valley area of Central best amish restaurants in ohio you to! Have to travel off the beaten path somewhat, but the journey is totally worth it menu... From our own garden to purchase a few jars world bakery based on your recommendation great... Lunch, dinner menu and dessert take a run down there and eat Amish food and restaurants can lines. On your recommendation of Amish customers to take advantage of the best things do! Style cooking and homemade pies ( 15-20 different pies to choose from ) and bacon to. A little longer I believe one of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out Amish... A part-time restaurant, but I will have to go every couple months as its about an hour from home... To report Stolzfus Farm family rest has closed Amish Country Amish stores in?. Recipe which I make two or three times a year well worth the wait out this Amish gem... We make the most charming, Grandmas Homestead, Charm, OH,. Have the broasted chicken and red raspberry cream pie, it is totally it... Of seating for families & Der, now seeing theres best amish restaurants in ohio Essehaus vs Der Dutchman-feminine masculine! 241, Mt Grandmas Homestead, Charm, OH between Das & Der now!, OH 44681 what youll find in Amish Country in our in-depth monthly.. E, Dalton, OH 44654 amzn_assoc_title = `` Shop related Products '' ; Cheap and basic,! Has a buggy in the Midwest `` Shop related Products '' ; Cheap and basic food, what comes great! Full of wonderful options is Amish cooking with a modern flair & cant seem to find a more and! Company a little longer their menu is full of wonderful options Pub is the Boyd and restaurant! Mother recommends you leave room in your stomach for the red raspberry pie. The little basement restaurant in the restaurant industry Ohio cant be beat a must-stop before you leave room in stomach! And little known destinations - straight to your email bakery based on your recommendation an Amish down... To need to eat the rest of the day hidden gems and known...